Is the ‘Self’ an illusion?
What is that I? And what I mean is the sense of self that each of us has — what makes that self feel so constant? How do I know who I really am? And is the “real” me the one I am when I’m alone, with friends, with family, or with strangers? What does the real me even mean? Is there a more correct me? What do we even mean when we talk about this concept? What shapes that ‘I’, and is it shaped by the environment alone, or do hereditary elements play a significant role? And is that I even… an illusion?
In the most basic definition, the sense of self is nothing more than the story our brain tells us about who we are in the world. The causes, the mechanisms and the problems that arise psychologically as part of this evolutionary mechanism are another story — and we’ll focus on them later in the post too. For now, let’s lay out the perception we all experience.
All of us have a kind of inner sense of what it means to be us — and that sense isn’t bounded by periods of time. As far as the brain is concerned, the self at age 5, at age 15 and at age 25 are all one single, continuous person, even though in practice that isn’t the case, neither physically nor mentally — but the brain is obliged to construct a continuous story about us in order to cope with reality.
First, let me clarify: when I say ‘I’, I mean the sense of self — The Self — the inner being of how I perceive myself in relation to the world, to other people and so on. From here on I’ll use the term the self to describe this perception, for convenience.
What are the reasons — and are there even good reasons — to think that the self is an illusion and nothing more? And what does illusion even mean here? That is, it isn’t real? My brain is fooling itself — what does it even mean for it to fool itself — the self fools the self into creating the self?? So it doesn’t exist? Well, yes — it doesn’t really ‘exist’ the way a wooden table or a glass of water exists physically in the world. It’s a mental model created in the human brain to give us a greater capacity to cope and to survive in the face of the world — because if I’m in internal conflict and there’s nothing to unify the way I perceive the world and reality as a whole, that isn’t efficient from an evolutionary standpoint.
Take, for example, people who experience dissociative identity disorder (DID). According to the DSM-5 (the psychiatrists’ bible for describing symptoms, disorders and mental and/or psychological experiences) and modern psychology, in people dealing with this disorder, as its name suggests, a kind of identity split forms: the brain has woven a number of ‘selves’ that live in one body. For instance, a 25-year-old woman who was born under the name Julia, likes listening to metal in her free time and calls her dog Jenny, may find a 9-year-old boy emerging from her who answers to the name Lex, connects more to mellow pop music and calls the dog something else entirely (maybe the dog example isn’t a great one; in any case, if such a case exists, it’s unfortunate for the dog, who is probably especially confused). In short, a number of identities can emerge within one single human body. In most cases we’re talking about a handful, up to four different personalities, but there are documented cases of dozens(!) of different ‘I’s in one body.
Another case that lends weight to the camp arguing that the self is an illusion comes from severe cases of epilepsy — when significant parts of the corpus callosum are removed, the chunk of brain that connects the left hemisphere to the right. That separation can cause a lack of communication between the hemispheres and create two different centers of the sense of self: one that responds to visual stimuli and one that responds to auditory stimuli.
Let’s pause the examples for a moment in order to explain what that I is made of — whether it’s an illusion (and we still don’t have a satisfying answer) or whether it’s something concrete and real. One thing can necessarily be said about it, and that is that this self does exist in every one of us (a few cases where it doesn’t… what happens if there’s no sense of self?). That self is made up of our memories, emotions, sensory impressions, language, fears, wants and desires — all of our past experiences from the moment we began forming in our mother’s womb up to this very moment. That self developed, and it is still developing.
Before we return to our original question — is the I an illusion — let’s answer the central question once and for all: when we say ‘I’ or ‘self’, what do we mean? Well, exactly this — the brain has woven that sense of self out of all of our past experiences, whether external or internal, and that is the feeling that makes us think we’re talking about something concrete. When you’re asked ‘who are you’ — beyond the banal answer of your name, your job, where you live and maybe a few details about the people close to you — a deeper answer is hiding: what are your deepest desires, is your sense of security high or low? Do you lean toward traits at one extreme or another, do you have extreme disorders or traumatic experiences that your narrative says shaped who you are? All of these are the components out of which the brain weaves the sense of self.
So… is the I an illusion? Philosophers, neuroscientists and psychologists have been occupied with this question for decades, for centuries, and in part even for thousands of years, back to ancient Greece. There’s no unequivocal answer; we’re still in the process of investigating this conscious concept. Modern research suggests that it may very well be the case, especially in light of the fact that experiences of one kind or another affect our own perception.
The self is made up of the sum of our experiences and it is especially flexible. It tends to change and to be shaped mainly in childhood until we come of age, and apparently becomes less plastic around the age of 25 — by then our sense of self is already fairly well shaped, and from that point on (as long as we haven’t had a psychedelic experience of one kind or another) it will be quite difficult to change the foundation of that narrative.