No, of course not — it’s ridiculous — only thinking, feeling entities with some kind of consciousness are capable of making decisions, right? How could a pine tree, or any tree of any kind, make a decision? They don’t even have a nervous system that could support it. Well — I’d like [to try to] argue otherwise, and in this mini-essay I’ll present a controversial(?) view — yes, pine trees, and like them other trees and plants and (almost) every organism there is, are capable of making decisions, and they do decide! And how is all of this connected to human consciousness and free will?

Wow, okay.. a fairly extreme claim, and some would even say a ridiculous one — before you read on, I have to stop and tell you a story about a particularly dear and beloved man named Menashe. Menashe woke up in the morning, brushed his teeth, made himself a matcha shake of a quality that wouldn’t embarrass the average Tel Aviv girl, left the house, got into his car and started driving. Suddenly the question that has crossed the mind of every single one of you, my honorable readers, crossed Menashe’s — “fuck, did I lock the house?”

Menashe is right at a decisive junction and he has to make a fateful decision — to drive a whole minute back to check whether he really did lock his front door, or to take the risk and continue on to his decidedly undesirable job (Menashe has been an accountant at a law firm for 18 years now, he’s a little tired of the routine). So — Menashe has to make a decision! What is really going on in his brain at the moment he wants to make that decision? What’s the difference between the decision he made to get up in the morning (and did he even make a decision to get up? it felt to him as if he just got up, that’s all), the decision to brush his teeth at all, and the decision to drive back home to check whether he locked the door? Is there a fundamental difference between those kinds of decisions? Spoiler: Menashe decided to keep driving and take the risk, and later, when he came home, he discovered that someone had stolen his television, his golf shoes and his chihuahua, who answers to the name Mushmush.

Apologies for boring you with the details of dear Menashe’s story, such a long story wasn’t necessary — at least now you’ve got the distinction between types of decisions in hand. Let’s try to get at the real nature and essence of different kinds of decisions — there are at least two: conscious decisions — the ones we make consciously, actively. And unconscious decisions — the ones we make without awareness, passively. [So then, can we even call a passive decision a decision? And if not, and it’s something entirely automatic, is it a decision? I’ll have to define what a ‘decision’ is in this context as well.]

Our pine trees do make decisions, and in a moment we’ll understand how all of this connects to free will — the decisions they make aren’t really made, since to “make” a decision you need some conscious entity that chooses between several options consciously, weighing the options on the basis of past events and experience or on the basis of some logical principle. When pine trees choose to grow in a particular direction they aren’t drawing up a list of pros and cons; from the outside it even looks as if there’s no “decision” at all — they just.. grow.

Now let’s look at a pine tree standing in the yard of our Menashe’s house — he planted it when he was 22, in the garden he inherited from the original grandpa Menashe. Over decades (Menashe is 48 today, no longer a young man) the tree grew tall, towering today at over 25 meters! My question to you is this — why do certain branches go out in one direction rather than another? Why does the tree lean slightly right rather than left? When the tree ran into an obstacle in the form of the roof of Menashe’s house, how did it “choose” to go around it, and why that way in particular?

Here is the core of our question — do pine trees decide? Well, yes! We’ve already answered that, so let’s be precise — pine trees make decisions as organisms with no nervous system and no capacity for thought — unconsciously. The tree doesn’t exercise judgment or run mental models to decide which direction to grow in — the sun guides it, and it tends to ‘choose’ the path that is ideal for it on the basis of many variables.

What are those variables? They are variables of 2 main kinds, divided into 2 categories:

  • Variables that depend on external factors beyond its control, such as a gust of wind, the intensity of the sun, clouds, where it was planted, and so on.
  • Variables that depend on internal factors beyond its control: heredity, what kind of tree it is, the strength of its branches, and so on.

And variables that depend on external and internal factors that are under its control (what does that mean? Well, the tree doesn’t decide consciously, but in light of all those variables we mentioned — the tree “decides” what to do and how; it has an illusion of choice, since it is at the mercy of all those prior events).

I promised in the first paragraph of this essay that I’d give an answer about how all of this connects to human consciousness and free will. My friends, this is the reason we’ve been talking about Menashe and his tree all this time, and this is the reason those questions came up, and it’s also the reason you stayed and read this far.

Why does any of this interest us in the first place? Well, in many senses — we are very much like the tree. The choices we make in our lives are also at the mercy of our heredity and our environment, of all those past events that brought us to the present we’re in and make us choose to eat a peach and not grapes, to marry Ann and not Tal, to study psychology and not economics. In a certain sense, many of our decisions, from the small and everyday ones to the big and meaningful ones, are a by-product of everything that happened in the past.