I’ve read and researched extensively about this phenomenon, known as the “Them vs. Us” bias — or, as psychologists prefer to call it, the in-group (for ‘us’) and the out-group (for ‘them’).
Below are some of my raw notes from random bursts of thought. For now I’m keeping them as they are; when I feel like it, I’ll refine this part. Underneath them is an article I wrote about the science behind it.
Raw notes
01
I think that in order to understand people in modern society, you need to know where they draw the line in their perspective on them and us — who is the them, and who is the us, for them.
We all have plenty of connections where this pattern shows up, but there’s always one (or a few) big THEM VS US in someone’s subjective mind that controls their role in society and how they see themselves.
May 20, 2022
02
From a different angle, but the same conclusion:
Being a black sheep is still being a sheep.
“It’s funny how many people think they are “non-conformist” when they are really just strict ideological adherents to a niche dogma. It’s kind of like a cult member thinking they are “non-conformist” because their cult is small. They are actually highly conformist — real “NPCs” if you will — they are just conforming to a fringe.”
— Alexander DatePsych
03
Layers, from the widest inward:
What exists vs. what doesn’t (at this layer a rock, a galaxy and a rabbit are all in my camp).
What’s alive vs. what’s inanimate (here every living organism, from E. coli and cyanobacteria to elephants and birds, is in my camp).
What’s human vs. what isn’t (all Homo sapiens are in my camp [unless you’re a scientist — or at least an anthropologist, primatologist, archaeologist, or anything in between — in which case even Neanderthals, Homo erectus and other hominins count too]).
This is where I aim to stop giving any meaningful interpretation or attention. I still notice and judge all the layers that follow — I just aim to eliminate any large influence they have on me. Briefly, they are:
- Religion (Jew or goy?)
- Nationality (Israeli or foreigner)
- Political camp (left or right)
- Family or not
- Circle of friends
Other small ones: football team fan · atheist · business owner · dreams of a nomad solo lifestyle · etc., etc.
04
It’s clearly understood that humans form groups around historical stories, sometimes imaginary ones rooted in culture, religion or nationality. I have no interest in letting my status as “part” of those groups influence how I treat other humans — it gets complicated, and there are too many biases and paradigms inside me regarding those groups.
05
Maybe instead of making your Us only your own country (i.e. nationalism), make your Us your own species. Some go as far as making their Us all living creatures — we call them hippies (kind of). And those hippies can be called the rebels of society, and their group is also a them: the hippies, against all the others — mainstream society.
For many hippies, “them” meant the established institutions, norms and authorities they saw as oppressive, materialistic and conformist: government, corporations, the military-industrial complex, traditional social norms, mainstream culture in general.
Inside their own bubble, the us for hippies might have been all living creatures — but seen from above, it isn’t really the case. Complicated stuff, I know. Maybe I’m wrong.
The science behind Us vs. Them, explained
3 October 2026
This short article is about the “Us vs. Them” mentality. It’s about the mindset we all fall into and how it affects your life. It’s about the science behind it, how it evolved, and why it evolved in the first place. It’s also about how it shapes your behavior and your social interactions.
Yes, it affects you too.
First, I have to say: if you think you’re immune to this mentality, you’re probably wrong. Being aware of a problem doesn’t mean you’re not affected by it. A few examples that might convince you: Jamie, who smoked cigarettes for 20 years despite the danger of cancer, got cancer. Emily, who drinks while driving despite the danger of accidents, dies in one. Liam, who presses snooze despite the danger of not waking up, doesn’t get up.
You can be aware of a problem and still be affected by it.
The so-called rebels of society are not outsiders. They’re just part of another group — most likely a minority one. They may see themselves as different and special, as if they have no group, no niche, as if they don’t conform to social norms. But all they did was move out of the popular groups and into subcultural divisions of smaller ones.
For example, if you’re part of the red pill community, you may have removed yourself from the blue pill folks and ‘left the matrix’ — but now you’re just in one of the smaller groups inside the red pill community. And if you’re part of the flat earthers around the globe, you removed yourself from the group of rational people and left the mainstream. Guess what? Now you’re just part of a smaller group inside your own community.
What is the Us vs. Them mentality?
“Us vs. Them” is a psychological concept — a mentality. It’s our evolutionary tendency to simplify people into two groups: “Us”, those we identify with, and “Them”, those who are different from us. It shapes how we interact with others, and it can be very harmful to those of us who don’t want to become irrational people who hate others simply because they’re black, Chinese, fans of a particular basketball team, or praying to a particular god.
If you’ve been on Earth for more than 20 minutes, you already know there are far too many people like that out there. That’s sad, because we’re supposed to be the intelligent ones here… aren’t we?
I think that if you truly want to understand people in modern times, you have to learn where they draw the line in their perspective on “them and us.”
What is their BIG defining them vs. us?
Most of the time we’ll see it in the form of religion, race, political party, gender and nation — but there are also arbitrary groups we create daily without even noticing: sports (Real vs. Barça), movies (Marvel vs. DC), political views.
The psychology
The origins of the theory go back about 50 years, to two psychologists: Henri Tajfel and his student John Turner. It’s known as Social Identity Theory, and it describes our psychological need to categorize ourselves into groups — specifically, to perceive our own groups as better than the external ones. We’re good, they’re bad. These social groups are useful; they serve a purpose, because they give us a sense of belonging, self-worth and, most importantly, identity — a sense of who we are in the world.
But add a mix of cognitive biases to that and you end up with individuals who define themselves solely by their group memberships. A big no-no, if you ask me. Now, unless you want to live like Tom Hanks in Cast Away for the rest of your life, you can’t really escape the influence of this mentality. So what can you do about it? Start with what’s within your control: be aware of the cognitive biases and deal with them effectively. Biases like stereotyping, in-group favoritism and confirmation bias can and will cloud your judgment of other people. And remember — it’s not just about knowing they exist, it’s about doing something about them.
Studies have shown us the absurd fact that people tend to favor their own group even when the difference between the groups is meaningless. Sometimes people prefer getting less if it means the other group gets less too. In a way, we really are messed up creatures. But we’re social creatures as well, and our brains are wired to divide the world into Us’s and Them’s.
Yes, we’ve learned that already. But why? Why do our brains have this tendency?
The biology
The answer lies in our evolutionary past, back when all humans lived in small tribes and had to fight other tribes over food, water and territory — yes, the things we all take for granted right now. Anthropologists think that, most likely, a mechanism evolved: a mindset that helped individuals handle that ancient social environment.
Think about it — if you treat all the others as potential threats, you get a better shot at staying alive. It became easy and useful for our minds to hate the ‘Them’ and love the ‘Us’. To sum up the evolutionary outlook in one sentence:
The “Us vs. Them” mentality is a survival strategy created by early human environments and the human psyche.
But while human societies evolved, our brains stayed exactly the same, and that’s where things get messy — because the strategy is no longer as useful as it was. We now see it in the form of discrimination, political polarization and nationalism.
We’ve answered the why. Let’s answer the what: what in the brain makes us act like this?
The neuroscience
We have a system in the brain called the limbic system. Part of it is a structure called the amygdala, strongly tied to emotional responses of fear and mistrust toward strangers. Another is the mesolimbic system, responsible for feelings of reward and pleasure — the stuff that increases our chances of survival.
And what increases our chances of survival? Our tribe, our people — US. And who do we fear, who threatens our survival? The other tribe — THEM.
So the amygdala makes us feel fear and mistrust toward ‘Them’, while the mesolimbic system makes us feel love and trust toward ‘Us’.
We’ve all heard of oxytocin, the famous hormone that strengthens pair bonding and mother-infant bonding. A study showed how oxytocin makes people more supportive within their own group: oxytocin promotes prosocial behavior, but only toward those we consider part of ‘Us’.
Now, instead of blaming evolution, the brain, oxytocin or the amygdala for being affected by this mentality — blame yourself. You can’t escape it completely, but you can tame it when it’s unnecessary. At the end of the day it’s your own responsibility to control your behavior and your actions. I think one of the most beautiful things about being human, as far as I’ve learned, is that we have the ability to overcome our innate primate desires instead of surrendering to them.
Stop reading right now and ask yourself two questions:
- What are my three BIG “Them vs. Us” in my life?
- How do they influence my social interactions and my actions toward others?
Once you have an answer to both, try to notice it while it’s happening. If you’re lucky enough, you’ll catch it at the right moment and be able to tell yourself: “damn, I don’t really have a good reason to hate these guys.”
A different outlook
Here’s a nice thought experiment to try. Imagine the day humanity discovers intelligent alien life. How dramatically would the concept of “Them vs. Us” change? In the case of a galactic war especially, we’d be far more united (and most likely destroyed). The way most of us see ‘our’ group would be so different. There’s a reason suffering in wars is so unifying: it gives humans a reason to be united, it makes us stronger against a common enemy. Maybe if we want to remove the barriers, we need a huge common enemy — like aliens?
And if most of us were working toward one common elite goal, like building a megaproject or fighting aliens, how great would we become?
Sources, references and resources:
- The science behind ‘us vs. them’ | Big Think — here
- Us vs. Them: Social Identity Theory | By Arcadia — here
- The Psychology of “Us-vs-Them” | Psychology Today — here
- The science of us vs. them | SPARK, Anythink Libraries — here
- Social Identity Theory — Wikipedia and Simply Psychology
- Why our brains see the world as us vs. them | Leslie Henderson — here
- Why society and the world are becoming divided | Julia Kolodko — here
- In-group bias in the minimal intergroup situation — here
- Social categorization and the process of intergroup bias — here
- On how our brains prioritize information about our own group over the other, even when we don’t consciously think about it — here
- The Neuropeptide Oxytocin Regulates Parochial Altruism in Intergroup Conflict Among Humans (oxytocin effects regarding your in-group) — here | Sci-Hub
- On cognitive biases and all that: the ideas in Dan Ariely’s and Daniel Kahneman’s best-selling books first exposed me to them, and to ways of dealing with them.